Do's and Don'ts of Email Compliance

Do's and Don'ts of Email Compliance

Sending marketing emails is a great way to stay connected with your audience, but it's important to make sure your mailings follow applicable regulations and email marketing best practices.

Email compliance is about more than following the law. Responsible sending practices also help protect your sender reputation, improve deliverability, and build trust with your contacts.

Whether you're sending a newsletter, promotional campaign, or automated email series, the following guidelines can help keep your mailings on the right track.

1. Build Your Mailing List Responsibly

One of the most important parts of email compliance is making sure you're sending messages to people who have an appropriate reason to receive them.

Do: Obtain Permission Before Sending

Whenever possible, use a clear opt-in process that allows contacts to actively agree to receive your marketing emails.

Good practices include:

  • Using signup forms that clearly explain what contacts are subscribing to.

  • Keeping records of when and how contacts subscribed.

  • Using double opt-in (also called confirmed opt-in) to verify that subscribers own the email addresses they provide.

  • Setting expectations about the type and frequency of emails contacts will receive.

Remember that someone providing their email address for one purpose does not automatically mean they have agreed to receive marketing emails.

Don't: Purchase or Rent Email Lists

Purchased, rented, and improperly acquired third-party email lists are prohibited.

These lists often contain contacts who have never agreed to receive messages from your organization. Sending to them can result in:

  • Increased spam complaints.

  • High bounce rates caused by invalid or outdated addresses.

  • Damage to your sending domain's reputation.

  • Potential violations of applicable email marketing regulations.

  • Reduced deliverability for future campaigns.

Similarly, avoid collecting email addresses from websites, social media profiles, or online directories without appropriate permission.

Best practice: Grow your audience organically through website signup forms, event registrations with clear marketing consent, and other permission-based methods.

2. Keep Your Contact Lists Healthy

Even a properly collected mailing list needs occasional maintenance. Contacts change email addresses, lose interest, or no longer wish to receive your messages.

Do: Regularly Review Your Mailing Lists

Keeping your lists up to date helps improve engagement and reduces the likelihood of sending unwanted emails.

Consider the following practices:

  • Remove or suppress addresses that have permanently failed delivery.

  • Review contacts who haven't engaged with your mailings for an extended period.

  • Use segmentation to send more relevant content.

  • Make sure unsubscribe requests are respected across your marketing campaigns.

  • Periodically review how older contacts were originally added to your list.

Don't: Automatically Resume Sending to Old or Unengaged Contacts

Just because someone subscribed several years ago doesn't necessarily mean they're still interested in receiving your messages.

Sending to an old or inactive list without reviewing its history can lead to increased spam complaints and delivery issues.

Before contacting an older audience, verify that you have an appropriate basis to email them and consider whether their original subscription expectations still apply.

Important: Never manually resubscribe someone who has unsubscribed unless they have subsequently provided valid authorization to receive your marketing messages.

3. Be Transparent About Who Is Sending the Email

Recipients should be able to easily identify your organization and understand what your message is about.

Do: Use Accurate Sender Information

Your email's From name, From address, and subject line should accurately represent your organization and the content of your message.

For example:

  • Good From name: ABC Company Newsletter

  • Good subject line: Your November Newsletter Is Here

  • Misleading subject line: URGENT: Your Last Chance Is Today

Use a recognizable sending address and avoid impersonating another person or organization.

Don't: Hide the Commercial Nature of Your Message

Avoid misleading recipients about the purpose of your email.

Commercial messages must be identifiable as advertisements when required by applicable law. This doesn't necessarily mean every marketing email needs a large "ADVERTISEMENT" label, but the nature of the message should be clear.

Do: Include Your Organization's Contact Information

Marketing emails should include the sender identification and contact information required by the laws that apply to the mailing.

For example, CAN-SPAM requires a valid physical postal address, while CASL has additional identification and contact information requirements.

Including your organization's name and appropriate contact information in the email footer is a good starting point.

4. Understand Email Authentication

Email authentication helps receiving mail servers determine whether a message is legitimately associated with the domain it claims to represent.
Three common authentication methods are:
  1. SPF (Sender Policy Framework): Identifies which mail servers are authorized to send email for a domain.
  2. DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail): Adds a digital signature that allows receiving servers to verify that a message was authorized by the signing domain and hasn't been improperly modified.
  3. DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance): Builds on SPF and DKIM to help protect against domain impersonation and establish how authentication failures should be handled.
These authentication methods are especially important for bulk senders, as mailbox providers such as Gmail and Yahoo have specific requirements for authenticating marketing messages.

Best practice: Make sure your sending domain is properly authenticated before beginning regular marketing campaigns.

Email authentication doesn't guarantee that your messages will reach the inbox, but it is an important part of maintaining reliable email delivery.


5. Make Unsubscribing Easy

Providing recipients with a simple way to stop receiving marketing emails is one of the most important compliance requirements.

Do: Include a Clear Unsubscribe Option

Your marketing emails should include a working unsubscribe mechanism that is easy to find and use.

A good unsubscribe experience should:

  • Make it clear how to stop receiving marketing messages.

  • Avoid unnecessary steps or complicated instructions.

  • Allow recipients to unsubscribe without logging into an account.

  • Process requests promptly.

  • Offer communication preferences when appropriate, without making those preferences an obstacle to unsubscribing entirely.

Some mailbox providers also require eligible bulk marketing messages to support one-click unsubscribe functionality.

Don't: Ignore or Circumvent Unsubscribe Requests

Once someone has opted out of your marketing messages, you should not continue sending them promotional content unless they subsequently provide valid authorization.

Avoid practices such as:

  • Reimporting unsubscribed contacts as active subscribers.

  • Moving unsubscribed contacts to another list to continue sending.

  • Requiring recipients to explain why they're unsubscribing.

  • Sending additional promotional emails asking recipients to reconsider their decision.

Important: Different regulations establish different deadlines for processing unsubscribe requests. As a best practice, process requests as soon as possible rather than waiting until the legal deadline.

6. Follow Responsible Sending Practices

Compliance isn't limited to the contents of your email. How frequently you send, who you target, and how recipients respond can also affect your sending reputation.

Do: Send Relevant Content

Try to send messages that align with what contacts originally subscribed to receive.

For example, someone who signed up for monthly product updates may not expect to receive daily promotional emails.

Segmenting your contacts based on their interests and preferences can help keep your content relevant.

Don't: Suddenly Increase Sending Frequency or Volume

Large, unexpected changes in sending behavior can negatively affect deliverability.

If you're introducing a new sending domain, significantly increasing your mailing volume, or expanding to a larger audience, consider gradually increasing your sending activity.

Likewise, avoid dramatically increasing how often you contact existing subscribers without communicating that change.

Do: Monitor Your Mailing Performance

Your mailing reports can help identify potential problems before they become more serious.

Pay particular attention to:

  • Bounce rates: A high number of failed deliveries may indicate outdated or improperly collected addresses.

  • Spam complaints: Recipients marking your messages as spam can negatively affect your sender reputation.

  • Unsubscribe rates: An unexpected increase may suggest that your content or sending frequency isn't meeting expectations.

  • Engagement trends: Declining opens and clicks may indicate that your audience is becoming less interested in your content.

While no single metric tells the whole story, monitoring these trends can help you make informed decisions about your sending practices.

7. Understand the Email Marketing Laws That Apply to You

Email marketing regulations vary by country and region. Depending on where your recipients are located and how your organization operates, multiple regulations may apply to your mailings.

Three important regulatory frameworks are CAN-SPAM, CASL, and GDPR.

CAN-SPAM Act (United States)

The CAN-SPAM Act establishes requirements for commercial email messages sent in the United States.

Some of its primary requirements include:

  • Do not use false or misleading sender information.

  • Do not use deceptive subject lines.

  • Clearly identify messages as advertisements when required.

  • Include a valid physical postal address.

  • Provide a clear way for recipients to opt out of future marketing messages.

  • Honor opt-out requests within 10 business days.

  • Monitor compliance when another organization sends marketing emails on your behalf.

Important distinction: CAN-SPAM generally does not require recipients to opt in before receiving commercial emails. However, permission-based sending remains a strongly recommended practice and may be required by other applicable laws.

For additional information, see the FTC's CAN-SPAM Compliance Guide.

CASL (Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation)

CASL establishes requirements for commercial electronic messages sent to recipients in Canada.

Unlike CAN-SPAM, CASL generally requires consent before sending commercial emails, unless an exception applies.

Consent may be:

  • Express consent: The recipient has actively agreed to receive commercial messages.

  • Implied consent: Consent exists under specific circumstances recognized by CASL, such as certain existing business relationships. Implied consent may be time-limited.

Additional requirements include:

  • Providing the required sender identification and contact information.

  • Including a functioning unsubscribe mechanism.

  • Keeping unsubscribe mechanisms valid for at least 60 days after sending.

  • Processing unsubscribe requests without delay and no later than 10 business days.

  • Maintaining appropriate records to demonstrate consent.

Important: Simply having someone's email address or having communicated with them previously does not automatically establish valid consent under CASL.

For additional information, see the CRTC's CASL guidance.

GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation, European Union)

GDPR governs the processing of personal data, including the collection and use of email addresses for marketing.

Organizations subject to GDPR must have a valid legal basis for processing personal data.

Consent is one possible legal basis, but other legal bases may apply in certain circumstances. Separate European electronic marketing rules, including the ePrivacy Directive and applicable national laws, also govern when marketing emails may be sent.

Important considerations include:

  • Collecting and using personal data lawfully, fairly, and transparently.

  • Clearly explaining how subscriber information will be used.

  • Obtaining valid consent when consent is the required legal basis.

  • Maintaining appropriate records of consent and other applicable legal bases.

  • Providing individuals with information about their privacy rights.

  • Respecting requests to withdraw consent or object to direct marketing.

  • Protecting personal information and retaining it only as appropriate for its lawful purpose.

When relying on consent, it must be freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous. Prechecked signup boxes generally do not meet these requirements.

Important: GDPR compliance alone does not establish permission to send marketing emails. Organizations must also consider applicable electronic communications and national marketing laws.

For additional information, see the European Commission's GDPR guidance.

8. Marketing Emails vs. Transactional Emails

Not every email is considered a marketing message.

Transactional or relationship emails generally communicate information related to an existing transaction, account, or service.

Common examples include:

  • Order confirmations.

  • Password reset instructions.

  • Shipping notifications.

  • Important account or service updates.

Marketing emails, on the other hand, typically promote products, services, events, or other commercial offerings.

The distinction matters because some regulations treat transactional messages differently from promotional messages.

However, adding promotional content to an otherwise transactional email can affect how that message is classified.

Best practice: Keep essential transactional communications focused on their intended purpose and avoid adding unnecessary marketing content.

Final Thoughts

Good email compliance practices help protect both your organization and the people receiving your messages.

By maintaining permission-based mailing lists, respecting recipient preferences, providing accurate sender information, and monitoring your sending practices, you can help build a healthier email marketing program.

Remember that email marketing regulations can change, and requirements may differ depending on your organization's location, your recipients, and the types of messages you send.

This article provides general educational guidance and is not a substitute for legal advice. If you're uncertain about which regulations apply to your organization, consult a qualified legal professional.

If you have questions about managing your mailings in Delivra, our Support team is happy to help.